Welcome to my Crime and Justice blog! I am a 19 year old criminal justice student at the University of Winnipeg. I advocate for prisoners' rights, human rights, equality and criminal justice/prison system reforms.
Showing posts with label Preliminary Hearing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Preliminary Hearing. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 16, 2010

Two police officers face trial for allegedly obstructing justice


Two Winnipeg police officers will stand trial on charges that they attempted to obstruct justice in connection to a drug investigation in the city's North End.
Consts. Graeme Beattie, 30, and Paul Clark, 41, have pleaded not guilty to charges of attempted obstruction of justice.
Beattie and Clark consented to stand trial in the Court of Queen's Bench after the conclusion of a preliminary hearing Wednesday morning.
The case has been remanded until July, but a trial date has not been set, according to a Manitoba courts spokesperson.
The officers are accused of falsifying notes and reports that led to a man being charged with drug trafficking in May 2008, according to court documents obtained by CBC News when Clark and Beattie were formally charged.
The case against the suspected drug dealer, 20, wound its way through the courts for months until the Crown stayed the charges against the man in October 2008 on the day his preliminary hearing was set to begin.
An internal police service investigation was launched a month later, and the officers were charged in April 2009.
A mandatory publication ban prevents the reporting of any evidence given at the preliminary hearing.
The officers remain on desk duties within the Winnipeg Police Service.
WINNIPEG - Two Winnipeg police officers have been ordered to stand trial on allegations they fabricated evidence to build a stronger case against a suspected drug dealer.
Const. Graeme Beattie, 31, and Const. Paul Clark, 42, have pleaded not guilty to obstruction of justice. Their preliminary hearing began last month and ended Wednesday with a judge ruling there is sufficient evidence to bring the case to a Queen’s Bench trial.
A court-ordered ban prevents details of the hearing from being published. No trial dates have been set. None of the allegations has been proven and both men are presumed innocent.
The pair were arrested in March 2009 after the Crown attorney stayed charges of trafficking and proceeds of crime against a 20-year-old man.
The charges read that police "did with intent to mislead fabricate report and notes, with intent that it should be used as evidence in an existing judicial proceeding."
The charges also state the officers made a "false statement" by accusing the young man of drug trafficking.
Both officers joined the police service in 2006 and were moved to administrative duties following their arrests.

Thursday, June 10, 2010

Preliminary hearing begins for woman charged with baby's kidnapping, attempted murder


WINNIPEG - A Manitoba judge has started hearing evidence against a Winnipeg woman charged with abducting and trying to kill a 14-month-old baby.

Nikita Solange Eaglestick, 20, has pleaded not guilty to several offences -- including attempted murder -- stemming from the September 2009 attack that made headlines across the country. Her two-day preliminary hearing began Thursday with provincial court Judge Theodore Lismer imposing a publication ban on specific details of the proceedings.
Lismer will have to determine if there is sufficient evidence to order Eaglestick to stand trial.
Eaglestick has been accused of grabbing the infant from a residence in the 100 block of Gilbert Avenue, then beating the girl’s head on a sidewalk until a bystander - hailed a hero by family members - intervened.
Vanessa Houle was initially rushed to hospital in critical condition but has made a full recovery. Eaglestick had no connection to the baby but had apparently been inside the home of the child’s mother drinking alcohol before the attack occurred. At the time, police said they didn’t know the motive for the incident.
Eaglestick has been in custody since her arrest. The Free Press previously revealed she was out on bail at the time of the incident after the Crown consented to her release days earlier, despite the fact she was facing a total of 14 criminal charges including nine alleged breaches of previous court orders stemming from the preceding two months.
None of the allegations have been proven and she is presumed innocent.

Monday, May 10, 2010

Stobbe ordered to stand trial for the killing of Rowbotham


A Manitoba judge has ordered a former provincial government executive to stand trial for the high-profile killing of his wife nearly a decade ago.
Mark Stobbe has pleaded not guilty to second-degree murder for the October 2000 slaying of Beverly Rowbotham at their home just north of Winnipeg. His three-week preliminary hearing has now ended with provincial court Judge John Guy ruling there is sufficient evidence to take the case to trial. No dates have been set.
A court-ordered ban prevents specific details of the hearing from being published.
Stobbe was arrested in 2008 following an extensive RCMP investigation. He had moved to Saskatoon, where he was serving as executive director of the Saskatchewan Craft Council. He has been free on bail since shortly after his arrest.
Rowbotham, 42, was found dead inside her tan Ford Crown Victoria in a gas station parking lot in Selkirk in the early morning of Oct. 25, 2000. Immediately after her killing, the RCMP assured the public there was no reason to fear a random killer was on the loose, but never said why.
Rowbotham, Stobbe and their children had moved from Regina about five months before the slaying when Stobbe accepted a senior position on the provincial cabinet's community and economic development committee. It co-ordinates major projects in Manitoba that require interdepartmental collaboration.
Stobbe had been a high-ranking adviser to former Saskatchewan premier Roy Romanow before coming to Manitoba. In the late 1980s he had also served as an assistant in the Saskatchewan constituency office of then-NDP MLA Pat Atkinson. Now NDP deputy leader, Atkinson refused comment Tuesday on Stobbe's arrest.
Rowbotham grew up in Regina and graduated with a BA from the University of Saskatchewan in 1978. She and Stobbe married in 1993 and lived in Regina, where she worked for several years in the Saskatchewan Public Service Commission until moving to Manitoba.

Husband to stand trial in Rowbotham slaying
A Manitoba judge has ordered a former provincial government executive to stand trial for the high-profile killing of his wife nearly a decade ago.
Mark Stobbe has pleaded not guilty to second-degree murder for the October 2000 slaying of Beverly Rowbotham at their home just north of Winnipeg. His three-week preliminary hearing ended last Friday with provincial court Judge John Guy ruling there is sufficient evidence to take the case to trial. No dates have been set. A court-ordered ban prevents specific details of the hearing from being published.
Stobbe was arrested in 2008 following an extensive RCMP investigation. He will remain free on bail and allowed to return to Saskatoon, where he has been serving as executive director of the Saskatchewan Craft Council.
Rowbotham, 42, was found dead inside her tan Ford Crown Victoria in a gas station parking lot in Selkirk in the early morning of Oct. 25, 2000. Immediately after her killing, the RCMP assured the public there was no reason to fear a random killer was on the loose, but never said why. Police believe Rowbotham was actually killed in her backyard but have never revealed a motive.
Rowbotham, Stobbe and their children had moved from Regina about five months before the slaying when Stobbe accepted a senior position on the provincial cabinet's community and economic development committee.
Stobbe had been a high-ranking adviser to former Saskatchewan premier Roy Romanow before coming to Manitoba.
Rowbotham grew up in Regina and graduated with a BA from the University of Saskatchewan in 1978. She and Stobbe married in 1993.

Monday, April 19, 2010

Rowbotham homicide case preliminary hearing begins


WINNIPEG — One of Manitoba’s most notorious criminal cases has finally landed in court.
Former provincial government executive Mark Stobbe began a three-week preliminary hearing Monday in connection with the 10-year-old death of his wife, Beverly Rowbotham, at their home just north of Winnipeg.

Stobbe has pleaded not guilty to second-degree murder. He was arrested in 2008 following an extensive RCMP investigation. Stobbe had moved to Saskatoon, where he was serving as executive director of the Saskatchewan Craft Council. He has been free on bail since shortly after his arrest.

A court-ordered ban prevents specific evidence of the preliminary hearing from being published. Provincial court Judge John Guy must decide if there is sufficient evidence to order Stobbe to stand trial.

Rowbotham, 42, was found dead inside her tan Ford Crown Victoria in a gas station parking lot in Selkirk in the early morning of Oct. 25, 2000. Immediately after her killing, the RCMP assured the public there was no reason to fear a random killer was on the loose, but never said why.

Rowbotham, Stobbe and their children had moved from Regina about five months before the slaying when Stobbe accepted a senior position on the provincial cabinet's community and economic development committee. It co-ordinates major projects in Manitoba that require interdepartmental collaboration.

Stobbe had been a high-ranking adviser to former Saskatchewan premier Roy Romanow before coming to Manitoba. In the late 1980s he had also served as an assistant in the Saskatchewan constituency office of then-NDP MLA Pat Atkinson. Now NDP deputy leader, Atkinson refused comment Tuesday on Stobbe's arrest.

Rowbotham grew up in Regina and graduated with a BA from the University of Saskatchewan in 1978. She and Stobbe married in 1993 and lived in Regina, where she worked for several years in the Saskatchewan Public Service Commission until moving to Manitoba.

IT has been nearly 10 years since Beverly Rowbotham was found dead in Selkirk, triggering an extensive police investigation that many feared would never lead to an arrest.
Now the man accused of the high-profile homicide has finally landed in court. Former provincial government executive Mark Stobbe began a three-week preliminary hearing Monday in connection with the 2000 slaying of his wife, Beverly Rowbotham, at their home just north of Winnipeg.
Stobbe has pleaded not guilty to second-degree murder. He was arrested in 2008 following an extensive RCMP investigation. Stobbe has been free on bail and living in Saskatoon, where he was serving as executive director of the Saskatchewan Craft Council. He has been free on bail since shortly after his arrest.
A court-ordered ban prevents specific evidence of the preliminary hearing from being published. Provincial court Judge John Guy must decide if there is sufficient evidence to order Stobbe to stand trial.
Rowbotham, 42, was found dead inside her tan Ford Crown Victoria in a gas station parking lot in Selkirk in the early morning of Oct. 25, 2000. Immediately after her killing, the RCMP assured the public there was no reason to fear a random killer was on the loose, but never said why.
Rowbotham, Stobbe and their children had moved from Regina about five months before the killing when Stobbe accepted a senior position on the provincial cabinet's community and economic development committee. It co-ordinates major projects in Manitoba that require interdepartmental collaboration.
Stobbe had been a high-ranking adviser to former Saskatchewan premier Roy Romanow before coming to Manitoba. In the late 1980s he had also served as an assistant in the Saskatchewan constituency office of then-NDP MLA Pat Atkinson.
Rowbotham grew up in Regina and graduated with a BA from the University of Saskatchewan in 1978. She and Stobbe married in 1993 and lived in Regina, where she worked for several years in the Saskatchewan Public Service Commission.
Stobbe filed a lawsuit against two insurance companies in 2003 for failing to pay him more than $215,000 following Rowbotham's death. The issue was later settled out of court when the companies agreed to pay. The Mounties called in an Alberta prosecutor to review the case in February 2001, but no charges were authorized. The RCMP said they opted for the out-of-province prosecutor because Stobbe held a high-ranking provincial government position at the time.
Stobbe has always maintained his innocence and the case appeared to be growing colder despite extensive interviews, forensic analysis and public pleas for information. The investigation suffered a significant blow in October 2001 when one of the lead investigators committed suicide. The RCMP cold-case unit took over the investigation in 2005 and police remained tight-lipped about the case.
Stobbe has spoken publicly only through his lawyer, Tim Killeen, who said in 2006 his client is focused on raising his two children "and hopes police ultimately come to a resolution of their investigation."


A former top Saskatchewan government adviser accused of killing his wife was in a Winnipeg courtroom on Monday for the start of a preliminary inquiry to test the evidence the Crown has against him.
Mark Stobbe, 52, is charged with second-degree murder in connection to the death of his wife, Beverley Rowbotham. He has always maintained his innocence.
A publication ban prevents the reporting of any evidence heard during the preliminary hearings, which are expected to last three weeks. If the presiding judge decides there's enough evidence for Stobbe to stand trial, proceedings could begin as early as June or July.
Stobbe was arrested in May 2008, nearly eight years after Rowbotham was found dead in her car at a gas station near Selkirk, Man. in October 2000. Investigators said they believed she had been beaten to death in the backyard of her home in nearby St. Andrews, then moved to Selkirk.
Stobbe, a one time top adviser to former Saskatchewan premier Roy Romanow, has been out on bail and living in Saskatoon since June 24, 2008.
Stobbe, Rowbotham and their sons moved to Manitoba from Regina about five months before Rowbotham's death, when Stobbe accepted a senior job on the Manitoba cabinet's community and economic development committee.
After his wife's death, Stobbe and his sons moved back to Saskatoon, where he's lived ever since.
Manitoba Justice has hired independent Crown counsel from B.C. to prosecute Stobbe because of his past government positions.
At the time Rowbotham died, Stobbe told investigators he had left the family home to go grocery shopping about 8:30 p.m. the day before her body was found. He had fallen asleep with their two sons, then five and three years old, he said, and called police at 1:30 a.m., when she hadn't returned home.

Hearing in Rowbotham murder underway 
A preliminary hearing has begun for a former Manitoba government official accused of killing his wife nearly 10 years ago.
Mark Stobbe, 52, is charged with second-degree murder in the killing of 42-year-old Beverley Rowbotham.
Stobbe, who once served as a senior advisor to Saskatchewan premier Roy Romanow, has been free on bail since the spring of 2008, a short time after his arrest.
The hearing before provincial court Judge John Guy is scheduled for three weeks. Details of the hearing cannot be printed due to a publication ban.
Because of Stobbe’s former connection to the provincial government, the case has been assigned to a prosecutor from B.C.
Rowbotham, a mother of two boys, was found dead in her car in a parking lot near Selkirk in October 2000. She had been bludgeoned to death.
Rowbotham and her family had moved to the province five months earlier after Stobbe accepted a job with a provincial economic development committee.
Stobbe moved to Saskatchewan following his wife’s death. At the time of his arrest he was executive director of the Saskatchewan Craft Council’s office in Saskatoon.
RCMP cold case investigators dealt with prosecutors in B.C. to charge Stobbe. Mounties were unable to deal directly with the Manitoba Crown Attorney’s office because of a potential conflict of interest.
The file was given to B.C.’s prosecutions branch in November 2007 for an opinion on whether there was enough evidence to charge a suspect, a Manitoba Justice official said at the time of Stobbe’s arrest.